New Jersey Divorce & Family Law Call 800-701-8747

Appellate Division Vacates Dismissal of Domestic Violence Restraining Order and Orders New Trial

In a significant decision under New Jersey’s Prevention of Domestic Violence Act, the Appellate Division in P.C.H. v. K.M., Docket No. A-1525-24, vacated a Family Part order dismissing a Temporary Restraining Order and remanded the matter for a new trial. P.C.H. v. K.M. was decided on September 28, 2026, and is an unpublished opinion. [njcourts.gov]

The plaintiff had obtained a Temporary Restraining Order alleging criminal sexual contact and harassment and later proceeded to trial seeking a Final Restraining Order under the Prevention of Domestic Violence Act. Following the trial, the court dismissed the TRO. At the same time, however, exercising what it described as its equitable authority, the trial court required the defendant to remain 500 feet away from the plaintiff and ordered that communications concerning the parties’ children take place through AppClose.

On appeal, the Appellate Division concluded that the trial court’s credibility findings were inconsistent with its ultimate determination. As a result, the appellate court vacated the December 13, 2024 order and the conditions imposed by the Family Part, and remanded the matter for a new trial.

Why This Decision Is Noteworthy

What makes the decision particularly noteworthy is the standard an appellant faces when challenging a Family Part judge’s factual and credibility determinations.

New Jersey appellate courts traditionally afford substantial deference to Family Part factual findings because of the Family Part’s special expertise in family matters. The principle associated with Cesare v. Cesare, 154 N.J. 394 (1998), is that factual findings supported by adequate, substantial, and credible evidence generally should not be disturbed on appeal. New Jersey appellate decisions continue to recognize this highly deferential standard.

Against that backdrop, obtaining appellate relief based upon the relationship between a trial court’s credibility findings and its ultimate conclusions is particularly significant. In P.C.H. v. K.M., the Appellate Division determined that the inconsistency was sufficient to require the dismissal to be vacated and the matter tried again.

The decision serves as an important reminder that deference to a trial court’s credibility determinations is substantial, but it is not absolute. A trial court’s ultimate ruling must remain consistent with and supported by its factual and credibility findings.

The appeal was argued by Siobhan M. Fuller-McConnell, with Siobhan M. Fuller-McConnell and Jamie B. Goldman on the briefs, on behalf of the appellant.

Because this is an unpublished Appellate Division opinion, it does not constitute precedent and its use in other cases is limited pursuant to Rule 1:36-3.

Read the Appellate Division decision

« Back to Resources

Saminski Fuller Family Law

Hablamos Español • Mówimy Po Polsku

Our divorce and family law attorneys can assist you from our multiple office locations in New Jersey:

221 River Street
9th Floor
Hoboken, NJ 07030
201-653-0300

123 South Avenue East
3rd Floor
Westfield, NJ 07090
908-301-1111

2500 Plaza 5, 25th floor
Harborside Financial Center
Jersey City, NJ 07311
201-795-5566

89 Headquarters Plaza
Suite 1467
Morristown, NJ 07960
800-701-8747

FacebookLinkedInAvvo - Rate your Lawyer. Get Free Legal Advice. Yelp

We are known as the divorce lawyers, family law attorneys, child support lawyers, custody lawyers, alimony lawyers and spousal support lawyers of Saminski Fuller Family Law. We represent clients in Northern New Jersey, Central New Jersey and Southern New Jersey. We represent clients in the communities of: Hudson County: Jersey City, Bayonne, Hoboken, Kearny, Guttenberg, Hackensack, Secaucus, Weehawken, West New York, Union City, North Bergen, Passaic County: Clifton, Bloomingdale, Haledon, Little Falls, Paterson, Pompton Lakes, Ringwood, Totowa, Wayne, West Milford, Woodland Park, Essex County: East Newark, Bloomfield, Cedar Grove, South Orange, Essex Fells, Glen Ridge, Maplewood, Montclair, Nutley, West Orange, Bergen County: Hackensack, Paramus, Fair Lawn, Englewood, Edgewater, Bergenfield, Teaneck, Rutherford, Hasbrouck, Heights, Fairview, Bogota, Union County: Westfield, Clark, Cranford, Fanwood, Kenilworth, Mountainside, Plainfield, Roselle, Elizabeth, Hillside, Scotch Plains, Summit, Linden, Morris County: Morristown, Randolph, Dover, Parsippany Troy Hills, Denville, Pequannock, Cedar Knolls, Whippany, Mount Olive, Hanover, Rockaway, Montville, Mount Arlington, Chester, Wharton, Madison, Freehold, New Brunswick, North Hudson, as well as residents of Hunterdon County, Ocean County, Monmouth County, Somerset County, Middlesex County and Warren County.